When is music bad, and why?
When one opens iTunes, Pandora or any music hosting site, dozens of artists burst from advertisements and panels with neon colors and profuse popularity: Taylor Swift, Iggy Azalea, Maroon 5, all the rest. Everyone’s heard of them, and their songs are identifiable within seconds.
Their immediate fame is bewildering, but becomes almost reasonable when one considers the artist’s music: it’s catchy. “Shake it Off” forces dancing whilst contagious love encompasses Azalea’s “Fancy” because it’s a fun, loose song.
I won’t deny they sound great.
I won’t deny that’s one reason to buy a song.
But I will proclaim that auditory-pleasing songs should never permit ignorance.
What defines this “ignorance?”
Let’s compare two songs: “Fancy,” mentioned above, and “Meant to Live” by Switchfoot.
Iggy Azalea, “Fancy”
Verse 3:
Still stuntin’, how you love that?
Got the whole world asking how I does that
Hot girl, hands off, don’t touch that
Look at it I bet you wishing you could clutch that
It’s just the way you like it, huh?
You’re so good, he’s just wishing he could bite it, huh?
Never turn down nothing,
Slaying these hoes, gold trigger on the gun like
Chorus:
I’m so fancy
You already know
I’m in the fast lane
From L.A. to Tokyo
Switchfoot, “Meant to Live”
Verse 1:
Fumbling his confidence
And wondering why the world has passed him by
Hoping that he’s bent for more than arguments
And failed attempts to fly, fly
Chorus:
We were meant to live for so much more
Have we lost ourselves?
Somewhere we live inside
Somewhere we live inside
We were meant to live for so much more
Have we lost ourselves?
Somewhere we live inside
Dreaming about Providence
And whether mice or men have second tries
Maybe we’ve been livin with our eyes half open
Maybe we’re bent and broken, broken
So, “Fancy” is a story about being awesome. And going to parties. Because that’s what famous people do. Oh, and make sure you have a hot body all the guys want to clutch before doing any of those things.
Switchfoot’s “Meant to Live” speaks of confusion in life, referencing social despair but instilling hope. It questions discrimination and what is right and wrong while focusing on a type of compassion-revolution to raise love amongst other humans.
The two songs compared provide blinding contrast between an unintelligent song and an educated one. A monologue on clubbing and being ornamental teaches nothing, but “Meant to Live” offers hope in a world of darkness.
Furthermore, many pop songs glorify objectification and idolization of women, things most humans proclaim to hate. Meghan Trainor’s “All About That Bass” says “every bit of us perfect,” but then says guys like “a little more booty to hold.”
While adolescents male and female face varied and similar trials, most teenage girls confront nightmarish, warped themes of body image and what actions will make others like them. A gargantuan measure of popular songs instruct girls to have a perfect* physique, then offer it to any, instilling the already horrid expectations of women.
Self-image affects men, too; and these songs define what the role of a woman and man is. If a guy isn’t attending parties and having sex with every girl he meets, he is living incorrectly. Nothing teaches courtesy — perhaps that is why holding doors open or pulling chairs out for women is becoming nonexistent.
Music like this is a hazard to avoid. Sophomore Grant Weber has similar thoughts on this dilemma. “I like [popular music] every now and then, but after a while it just gets annoying because the meaning just isn’t there,” Weber said. “There just doesn’t seem to be any meaning to it; it’s just whatever the artist feels like at the moment. It’s not anything that will make you think anything profound.
While songs subjugating women and chanting vows of questionable morals have diffused and spread across miles of media, Weber has found his selection of alternatives.
“As far as lyrics are concerned, I definitely like a lot of the harder rock Christian bands like Nine Lashes, Thousand Foot Crutch, um, Love and Death,” he said. “As far as the beat, I like a lot of stuff from Monstercat like Tristam.”
The amount of bad music is astounding, but the quality of healthy songs overrides it. Within the digital tempests of the craft, boundless havens of brilliant and intelligent compositions defend listeners from the toxic messages of popular music.
* Ladies. You are beautiful. I’ve seen the effects of debilitating music amid other dangerous things and seeing gorgeous girls think they’re ugly kills me.
You are brilliant and lovely and kind.
brian • Mar 19, 2015 at 2:30 pm
Micah Summers argues that music can be bad. She claims that the song Fancy is unintelligible due to its bad lyrics. Summers develops this claim by first stating the lyrics and chorus of the song. Summers states that the lyrics questions discrimination and what is wrong. Lastly the author says a monologue on clubbing and being ornamental teaches nothing. MIcah Summers’ purpose is to warn the listeners of these songs in order to fully understand and realize what they are listening to. This work is significant because it is important to understand completely what the singer is really saying and realize that to some degree it is not okay.
Did these words explain your article correctly?
Kyler Fredrickson • Mar 19, 2015 at 9:25 am
Micah Summers argues that some music promotes questionable morals while other music promotes love among all humans. He/she claims that Iggy Azalea’s ‘Fancy’ promotes questionable morals while Switchfoot’s ‘Meant to Live’ promotes love among all humans.
Summers developed this first claim by first saying how ‘Fancy’ promotes ignorance while ‘Meant to Live’ speaks confusion in life. Fancy says how you have to live your life in order to have a good time. Lastly, the author says that songs such as fancy cannot define us or who we are or how we should act.
Micah Summers’ purpose is to inform reader different types of music can promote different lifestyles in order to persuade readers not to let songs define who they are. This work is significant because it gives actual songs as examples of how the could lead different life styles.
Kyler Fredrickson • Mar 19, 2015 at 9:29 am
Do you agree with my response?
Madeline Holway • Mar 13, 2015 at 12:12 pm
I think that it’s a little contradictory to be angry that Iggy Azealia is celebrating being awesome on her own in Fancy while criticizing Meghan Trainor for celebrating being awesome for guys in All About That Base. (Nonwithstanding, I still disapprove of Iggy)
Renee Nienhaus • Nov 26, 2014 at 10:18 am
Thank you micah, music has a big influence on teenagers lives so listening to something that has a positive impact is crucial
Susan Swanson • Nov 10, 2014 at 4:45 pm
Thank you Micah! Important stuff to think about. it would be great if more of that wholesome music was played on campus at lunch…more uplifting.